Behavior Driven Development

Behavior Driven Development (BDD) is a popular software development methodology. BDD is considered an extension of TDD, and is greatly inspired by Agile practices. The primary reason to choose BDD as your development process is to break down communication barriers between business and technical teams. BDD encourages the use of automated testing to verify all documented features of a project from the very beginning. This is why it is common to talk about BDD in the context of test frameworks (like CodeceptJS). The BDD approach, however, is about much more than testing - it is a common language for all team members to use during the development process.

What is Behavior Driven Development

BDD was introduced by Dan North. He described it as:

outside-in, pull-based, multiple-stakeholder, multiple-scale, high-automation, agile methodology. It describes a cycle of interactions with well-defined outputs, resulting in the delivery of working, tested software that matters.

BDD has its own evolution from the days it was born, started by replacing "test" to "should" in unit tests, and moving towards powerful tools like Cucumber and Behat, which made user stories (human readable text) to be executed as an acceptance test.

The idea of story BDD can be narrowed to:

By writing every feature in User Story format that is automatically executable as a test we ensure that: business, developers, QAs and managers are in the same boat.

BDD encourages exploration and debate in order to formalize the requirements and the features that needs to be implemented by requesting to write the User Stories in a way that everyone can understand.

By making tests to be a part of User Story, BDD allows non-technical personnel to write (or edit) Acceptance tests.

With this procedure we also ensure that everyone in a team knows what has been developed, what has not, what has been tested and what has not.

Ubiquitous Language

The ubiquitous language is always referred as common language. That is it's main benefit. It is not a couple of our business specification's words, and not a couple of developer's technical terms. It is a common words and terms that can be understood by people for whom we are building the software and should be understood by developers. Establishing correct communication between this two groups people is vital for building successful project that will fit the domain and fulfill all business needs.

Each feature of a product should be born from a talk between

which are known in BDD as "three amigos".

Such talks should produce written stories. There should be an actor that doing some things, the feature that should be fulfilled within the story and the result achieved.

We can try to write such simple story:

As a customer I want to buy several products
I put first product with $600 price to my cart
And then another one with $1000 price
When I go to checkout process
I should see that total number of products I want to buy is 2
And my order amount is $1600

As we can see this simple story highlights core concepts that are called contracts. We should fulfill those contracts to model software correctly. But how we can verify that those contracts are being satisfied? Cucumber introduced a special language for such stories called Gherkin. Same story transformed to Gherkin will look like this:

Feature: checkout process
  In order to buy products
  As a customer
  I want to be able to buy several products

  Scenario:
    Given I have product with $600 price in my cart
    And I have product with $1000 price
    When I go to checkout process
    Then I should see that total number of products is 2
    And my order amount is $1600

CodeceptJS can execute this scenario step by step as an automated test. Every step in this scenario requires a code which defines it.

Gherkin

Let's learn some more about Gherkin format and then we will see how to execute it with CodeceptJS. We can enable Gherkin for current project by running gherkin:init command on already initialized project:

codeceptjs gherkin:init

It will add gherkin section to the current config. It will also prepare directories for features and step definition. And it will create the first feature file for you.

Features

Whenever you start writing a story you are describing a specific feature of an application, with a set of scenarios and examples describing this feature. Let's open a feature file created by gherkin:init command, which is feature/basic.feature.

Feature: Business rules
  In order to achieve my goals
  As a persona
  I want to be able to interact with a system

  Scenario: do something
    Given I have a defined step

This text should be rewritten to follow your buisness rules. Don't think about a web interface for a while. Think about how user interacts with your system and what goals they want to achieve. Then write interaction scenarios.

Scenarios

Scenarios are live examples of feature usage. Inside a feature file it should be written inside a Feature block. Each scenario should contain its title:

Feature: checkout
  In order to buy product
  As a customer
  I need to be able to checkout the selected products

Scenario: order several products

Scenarios are written in step-by-step manner using Given-When-Then approach. At start, scenario should describe its context with Given keyword:

  Given I have product with $600 price in my cart
  And I have product with $1000 price in my cart

Here we also use word And to extend the Given and not to repeat it in each line.

This is how we described the initial conditions. Next, we perform some action. We use When keyword for it:

  When I go to checkout process

And in the end we are verifying our expectation using Then keyword. The action changed the initial given state, and produced some results. Let's check that those results are what we actually expect.

  Then I should see that total number of products is 2
  And my order amount is $1600

This scenarios are nice as live documentation but they do not test anything yet. What we need next is to define how to run those steps. Steps can be defined by executing gherkin:snippets command:

codeceptjs gherkin:snippets

This will produce code templates for all undefined steps in all feature files of this suite. It will also place stub definitions into step_definitions/steps.js file. Our next step will be to define those steps and transforming feature-file into a valid test.

Step Definitions

Step definitions are placed in JavaScript file with Given/When/Then functions that map strings from feature file to functions:

const I = actor();

// you can provide RegEx to match corresponding steps
Given(/I have product with \$(\d+) price/, (price) => {
  I.amOnPage('/products');
  I.click(`.product[data-price=${price}]`);
  I.click('Add to cart');
});

// or a simple string
When('I go to checkout process', () => {
  I.click('Checkout');
});

// parameters are passed in via Cucumber expressions
Then('I should see that total number of products is {int}', (num) => {
  I.see(num, '.cart');
});
Then('my order amount is ${int}', (sum) => { // eslint-disable-line
  I.see('Total: ' + sum);
});

Steps can be either strings or regular expressions. Parameters from string are passed as function arguments. To define parameters in a string we use Cucumber expressions

To list all defined steps run gherkin:steps command:

codeceptjs gherkin:steps

To run tests and see step-by step output use --steps optoin:

codeceptjs run --steps

To see not only business steps but an actual performed steps use --debug flag:

codeceptjs run --debug

Advanced Gherkin

Let's improve our BDD suite by using the advanced features of Gherkin language.

Background

If a group of scenarios have the same initial steps, let's that for dashboard we need always need to be logged in as administrator. We can use Background section to do the required preparations and not to repeat same steps across scenarios.

Feature: Dashboard
  In order to view current state of business
  As an owner
  I need to be able to see reports on dashboard

  Background:
    Given I am logged in as administrator
    And I open dashboard page

Steps in background are defined the same way as in scenarios.

Tables

Scenarios can become more descriptive when you represent repeating data as tables. Instead of writing several steps "I have product with :num1 $ price in my cart" we can have one step with multiple values in it.

  Given i have products in my cart
    | name         | category    | price  |
    | Harry Potter | Books       | 5      |
    | iPhone 5     | Smartphones | 1200   |
    | Nuclear Bomb | Weapons     | 100000 |

Tables is a recommended ways to pass arrays into test scenarios. Inside a step definition data is stored in argument passed as DataTable JavaScript object. You can iterate on it like this:

Given('I have products in my cart', (table) => { // eslint-disable-line
  for (const id in table.rows) {
    if (id < 1) {
      continue; // skip a header of a table
    }

    // go by row cells
    const cells = table.rows[id].cells;

    // take values
    const name = cells[0].value;
    const category = cells[1].value;
    const price = cells[1].value;
    // ...
  }
});

Examples

In case scenarios represent the same logic but differ on data, we can use Scenario Outline to provide different examples for the same behavior. Scenario outline is just like a basic scenario with some values replaced with placeholders, which are filled from a table. Each set of values is executed as a different test.

  Scenario Outline: order discount
    Given I have product with price <price>$ in my cart
    And discount for orders greater than $20 is 10 %
    When I go to checkout
    Then I should see overall price is "<total>" $

    Examples:
      | price | total |
      | 10    | 10    |
      | 20    | 20    |
      | 21    | 18.9  |
      | 30    | 27    |
      | 50    | 45    |

Long Strings

Text values inside a scenarios can be set inside a """ block:

  Then i see in file "codecept.json"
"""
{
  "output": "./output",
  "helpers": {
    "Puppeteer": {
      "url": "http://localhost",
      "restart": true,
      "windowSize": "1600x1200"
    }
"""

This string can be accessed inside a content property of a last argument:

Then('Then i see in file {string}', (file, text) => {
  // file is a value of {string} from a title
  const fileContent = fs.readFileSync(file).toString();
  fileContent.should.include(text.content); // text.content is a value
});

Tags

Gherkin scenarios and features can contain tags marked with @. Tags are appended to feature titles so you can easily filter by them when running tests:

codeceptjs run --grep "@important"

Tag should be placed before Scenario: or before Feature: keyword. In the last case all scenarios of that feature will be added to corresponding group.

Configuration

"gherkin": {
  "features": "./features/*.feature",
  "steps": [
    "./step_definitions/steps.js"
  ]
}

Tests vs Features

It is common to think that BDD scenario is equal to test. But it's actually not. Not every test should be described as a feature. Not every test is written to test real business value. For instance, regression tests or negative scenario tests are not bringing any value to business. Business analysts don't care about scenario reproducing bug #13, or what error message is displayed when user tries to enter wrong password on login screen. Writing all the tests inside a feature files creates informational overflow.

In CodeceptJS you can combine tests written in Gherkin format with classical acceptance tests. This way you can keep your feature files compact with minimal set of scenarios, and write regular tests to cover all cases. Please note, feature files will be executed before tests.

To run only features use --features option:

codeceptjs run --features

You can run a specific feature file by its filename or by grepping by name or tag.

To run only tests without features use --tests option:

codeceptjs run --tests

done()